On Pittsburgh and Progressive Enhancement

First off, Pittsburgh and Progressive Enhancement have nothing in common. However, I did just take a trip to Pittsburgh this past week and did some thinking on one of my favorite topics: Progressive Enhancement.

I’ve been thinking in recent months that progressive enhancement is an obsolete concept, at least in most circumstances and where it is not specifically dictated by requirements or regulations.

Certainly, JavaScript and Ajax are all the rage. Mobile devices are now as powerful as desktops with browsers equal to their desktop counterparts. Users expect rich functionality in web applications, which means JavaScript and DHTML. It is a waste of time and effort to build a non- JavaScript version of an application if 99% of your users will not see it. Supporting non JavaScript clients will also require considerable additional work.

But none of the above statements are true.

I took the trip Pittsburgh without a laptop, only a Blackberry Pearl and an iPod Touch. The Pearl is a bit old and always ran JavaScript questionably if at all and it only runs on a slow EDGE network. I therefore did not expect much from it.  However the Touch is an incarnation of the greatest device ever invented , the iPhone (please see the sarcasm here). I expected to be able to  do simply web-based tasks on the Touch, especially over its WiFi connection.

The only task I really needed to do that week was maintain my Ning site; essentially approve photos that are posted by users  and answering  messages from users if needed.

Unfortunately, neither device handled this simple task. While the devices share some of the blame, the fault is mostly Ning’s for not providing a simple non- JavaScript implementation of the needed functionality. Approving photos on Ning is as simple as opening the photos to approve page and clicking the “approve all” button (assuming you  want to approve all ). A pop up confirmation box is then displayed where you can confirm or cancel. When navigating to the page with the Blackberry, with JavaScript turned off by default, I was  informed  that JavaScript was required to view this page. After turning on JavaScript and clicking “approve all”, I was brought back to the top of the page with no apparent action or result. I reproduced this several times without successfully approving any photos. Of course, as I said before, I didn’t expect much from the Blackberry. That is why I had the iPod. However, it did the exact same thing and I was unable to approve the photos. I am not sure why the Touch didn’t work, but the functionality here is so basic, Ning could easily provide a static confirmation page for non JavaScript enabled browsers, and through progressive enhancement, enable the pop up for JavaScript enabled browsers.

While in Pittsburgh, I also tried to check my remaining  T-Mobile  minutes. I couldn’t connect to the T-Zones application ( a native app that comes installed) so I tried to access tmobile.com. I was curtly   informed the site didn’t support blackberry. This from the company that sold me the Blackberry and on the site where I can manage my Blackberry.

On a positive note, let me give kudos to Google’s excellent mobile Blackberry Apps. Gmail and Goggle Maps are extremely usable on the Pearl. I removed my native blackberry email account after accessing it through the Gmail mobile app.  Google Maps is also excellent, complete with traffic and satellite view and directions, but the T-Mobile connection speed made the experience a bit painful.

Right now, native applications are definitely the state of the art for mobile devices. Too bad they require custom development for each platform. I certainly imagine that a model driven approach than generates runtimes for multiple platforms may be more feasible in the future. The other option is that HTML sites, specifically HTML 5, allow browser based apps to provide a comparable experience and  supplant native apps. I would put my money in that category (actually I am). Maybe I am just too lazy, or too efficient, to want to rewrite apps for every platform I want to support.

I wrote a blog a while back about stumbleupon.com and how it didn’t support Oopera at the time and did not even let me proceed with that browser. I am not sure if it currently supports Opera (I have to think it does by now) but I still see sites that don’t support all browsers. HBO.com recommended to me only last night that I ditch Opera and I use IE or Mozilla. At least it gave me the option to proceed at my own risk. I took the risk and did not have a problem.

Progressive enhancement is still in my opinion the best way to develop web applications. The preferred approach is to build the app in three stages (for the initial release/revision). First build out the content layer (XHTML).  This step allows you to develop the necessary components that make up the core of the application, the guts of the M, the V, and the C. At this point, I usually am working with a raw HTML interface, perhaps with a bit of CSS just to make it usable. There may be some pages where the effort to do a non- JavaScript page is much more difficult and cumbersome to the user. In this case, It may make sense to require JavaScript for that specific module

Secondly, Style it (with CSS).  Add colors, positioning, etc.

Finally, and only where needed, add dynamic behavior with  JavaScript. I highly recommend jQuery for this.

The versions produced in each of these steps should be fully functional to the extent possible. This approach lets you focus on the basics of the application , foundation up, and not get caught up in what you think the behavior will be needed. Some of that may not be know early on  in the project.   Please understand this is only a very brief overview of my development process. I am not advocating a waterfall approach, only progressive development through progressive enhancement.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s